Ah, the penny loafer. A timeless classic, a symbol of preppy style, and a footwear choice that has graced the feet of generations. But there’s a question that has lingered in the minds of loafer enthusiasts for decades: should you actually put pennies in those little slots?
It seems like such a natural fit, doesn’t it? The shoe’s name practically begs for it. Yet, the answer isn’t as straightforward as you might think. We’ll delve into the history, the practicality, and the style implications of this iconic shoe customization. Prepare yourself for a journey through the world of leather, copper, and the enduring allure of the penny loafer.
This article will explore the origins of the penny loafer, the reasons behind the penny slot, the pros and cons of inserting pennies, and the modern perspective on this age-old tradition. Get ready to have your loafer-loving mind blown!
The Genesis of the Penny Loafer: A Brief History
Before we can decide whether to put pennies in penny loafers, let’s rewind the clock and understand where this shoe came from. The penny loafer’s story begins in Norway, with the ‘weejun’ (Norwegian) loafer. These simple, slip-on shoes were brought to the United States in the 1930s and quickly gained popularity. The G.H. Bass Company, an American shoe manufacturer, is widely credited with popularizing the penny loafer in the early 1930s. They adapted the Norwegian design, adding the distinctive leather strap across the vamp (the top of the shoe) with a diamond-shaped cutout.
This design element, the saddle strap with the diamond-shaped cutout, is the key. Why was it there? Initially, it was purely decorative. However, the story goes that students, particularly in the Ivy League, found the cutout a convenient place to stash a penny or two. The exact origin of this practice is debated, but the most popular theory is that it was a practical solution for students who needed to make a phone call (which, at the time, cost a penny) or had a few pennies to spare for emergencies. Another theory suggests that the pennies were used for good luck.
The penny loafer’s rise to fame coincided with the rise of preppy style. It became a staple in college wardrobes and a symbol of youthful sophistication. The penny loafer wasn’t just a shoe; it was a statement. It spoke of a certain lifestyle, a certain level of education, and a certain appreciation for classic style.
Why the Penny Slot Exists: Beyond Aesthetics
The cutout on the saddle strap wasn’t initially designed for pennies. Its initial purpose was purely decorative. However, over time, its functionality evolved, and the penny slot became an integral part of the penny loafer’s identity. Here’s a deeper dive into the reasons behind the slot:
- Decorative Functionality: The primary reason for the cutout was to add visual interest and distinguish the loafer from other slip-on shoes. It provided a clean, streamlined design.
- Adaptation and Evolution: As the shoe gained popularity, the cutout was adapted for practical use. Students and others realized it was a convenient place to store a penny, which became useful at payphones.
- Symbolic Significance: The penny became a symbol of good luck, prosperity, and the carefree attitude of youth. The penny in the loafer was also a subtle sign of wealth and education.
- Marketing and Branding: Shoe manufacturers embraced the penny slot’s association with the shoe. They understood that the penny was a key part of the loafer’s appeal.
The penny slot’s evolution from a purely aesthetic feature to a functional and symbolic element is a testament to the loafer’s enduring appeal and the adaptability of style. It shows how a simple design detail can become a cultural icon.
The Pros of Putting Pennies in Your Penny Loafers
So, what are the advantages of actually putting pennies in your penny loafers? Let’s explore the upsides: (See Also: How to Prevent Loafers From Creasing: Ultimate Guide)
- Nostalgia and Tradition: For many, inserting pennies is a nostalgic nod to the shoe’s history and the traditions associated with it. It’s a way to connect with the past and celebrate a classic style.
- Conversation Starter: The presence of pennies in your loafers can be a conversation starter. It’s a subtle detail that can attract attention and spark discussions about fashion, history, and personal style.
- Subtle Personalization: Putting pennies in your loafers adds a touch of personalization. It’s a way to make your shoes uniquely yours and express your individual style.
- Historical Accuracy: If you’re going for a vintage or preppy look, inserting pennies can add to the authenticity of your outfit. It’s a small detail that can make a big difference in achieving a specific aesthetic.
- Good Luck Charm: Some people believe that carrying a penny brings good luck, and putting it in your loafer could be a way to keep that luck with you throughout the day.
These pros highlight the enduring appeal of the penny loafer and the tradition of inserting pennies. It’s a small detail that can add a lot of personality to your look.
The Cons of Putting Pennies in Your Penny Loafers
Despite the charm and tradition, there are also some drawbacks to putting pennies in your penny loafers. Here’s a look at the downsides:
- Potential for Damage: Pennies can scratch the leather of the shoe over time, especially if they are frequently inserted and removed. The constant friction can wear down the leather around the slot.
- Loss of Pennies: Pennies can fall out, especially if the slot is loose or if you’re engaging in activities that involve a lot of movement. Losing a penny can be frustrating, and you might not even realize it’s gone until it’s too late.
- A Dated Look: While the penny loafer is a classic, the practice of putting pennies in them can sometimes appear dated, especially if not done well. It’s a style choice that can make you look like you’re stuck in the past.
- Impracticality: Pennies aren’t exactly the most useful form of currency these days. The practicality of having a penny in your shoe is questionable in the modern era.
- Maintenance: You may need to clean the penny slot and the pennies themselves to prevent tarnish and maintain the shoe’s appearance.
These cons highlight the practical considerations that need to be weighed when deciding whether or not to put pennies in your penny loafers. It’s a balance between tradition and practicality.
Alternative Items to Consider
While the penny is the most common item placed in a penny loafer, you can consider a few alternatives:
- Foreign Currency: Small coins from other countries can be a fun and unique way to personalize your loafers.
- Small Charms: Tiny charms or trinkets can be inserted for a touch of whimsy.
- Miniature Objects: Consider small, flat objects that fit the slot, like a folded piece of paper with a personal message.
- Nothing at All: Sometimes, the empty slot looks best, allowing the design of the shoe to speak for itself.
These alternatives offer a way to customize your loafers while avoiding some of the drawbacks of using pennies.
Caring for Your Penny Loafers
Whether you choose to put pennies in your loafers or not, proper care is essential to keep them looking their best. Here are some tips:
- Cleaning: Regularly clean your loafers with a soft cloth or brush to remove dirt and dust. Use a leather cleaner and conditioner to keep the leather supple and prevent cracking.
- Storage: Store your loafers in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight. Use shoe trees to help maintain their shape.
- Protection: Protect your loafers from the elements by applying a leather protectant spray. This will help repel water and prevent stains.
- Polishing: Polish your loafers regularly to keep the leather shiny and enhance their appearance. Match the polish color to your shoe color.
- Professional Care: If your loafers are damaged or need extensive cleaning, consider taking them to a professional shoe repair shop.
Proper care will ensure that your penny loafers last for years and maintain their classic appeal.
Modern Style: The Penny Loafer Today
The penny loafer’s popularity has never truly waned. It has adapted to the times and continues to be a versatile shoe. Here’s how it’s styled today: (See Also: Are Black Loafers in Style? A Fashion Enthusiast’s Guide)
- Casual: Penny loafers pair well with jeans, chinos, and shorts. They provide a touch of sophistication to a relaxed outfit.
- Business Casual: Loafers are a great choice for business casual settings. They look good with dress pants, blazers, and button-down shirts.
- Formal: While less common, penny loafers can be dressed up with a suit for a more relaxed take on formal wear. Choose a darker leather and ensure the shoes are polished.
- Modern Variations: Loafers come in various styles, including different leather types, colors, and embellishments. Choose the style that best suits your personal taste.
- The Penny Debate: The modern approach to the penny is more relaxed. Some people still opt for the classic penny, while others prefer to leave the slot empty. The choice is yours.
The penny loafer’s versatility allows it to be adapted to various styles and occasions. It’s a testament to its enduring appeal.
Penny Loafer Materials: A Deep Dive
Penny loafers are typically crafted from high-quality leather, though variations exist. Understanding the materials helps in proper care and appreciating the craftsmanship:
- Leather: The most common material, offering durability, flexibility, and a classic look. Full-grain leather is the highest quality.
- Suede: Provides a softer, more casual look. Requires more care to prevent water damage and staining.
- Patent Leather: A shiny, lacquered finish often used for dressier occasions.
- Synthetic Materials: Used in some modern loafers as a more affordable option.
- Construction: The way the shoe is made impacts its durability and comfort. Look for Goodyear welt construction for the highest quality.
The choice of material affects the look, feel, and longevity of the loafer. Selecting the right material is an important part of the buying process.
Sizing and Fit: Getting It Right
A well-fitting penny loafer is essential for comfort and style. Here’s how to ensure the right fit:
- Length: Your toes should not be cramped. There should be about a thumb’s width of space between the end of your longest toe and the end of the shoe.
- Width: The shoe should be snug but not tight across the widest part of your foot.
- Heel Fit: Your heel should not slip excessively when you walk.
- Break-in: New leather loafers may require a break-in period. Wear them for short periods at first to allow the leather to soften.
- Consider Socks: Wear the type of socks you’ll typically wear with the loafers when trying them on.
Proper sizing ensures comfort and prevents blisters. Take your time when trying on loafers to find the perfect fit.
Famous Penny Loafer Wearers: Style Icons
The penny loafer has been a favorite of many style icons throughout history. These individuals have helped cement the shoe’s place in fashion:
- John F. Kennedy: The epitome of preppy style, often seen in penny loafers.
- Audrey Hepburn: A fashion icon who frequently incorporated loafers into her stylish ensembles.
- Steve McQueen: A symbol of cool, often wore penny loafers with casual outfits.
- James Dean: Another icon, known for his rebellious style, which sometimes included penny loafers.
- Modern Influencers: Today, celebrities and fashion influencers continue to embrace the penny loafer.
These style icons demonstrate the enduring appeal and versatility of the penny loafer.
Penny Loafer Variations: Exploring the Styles
Penny loafers come in various styles, each with its own character and appeal. Here’s a look at some popular variations: (See Also: How to Know Sizing for Loafers: A Comprehensive Guide)
- Classic Penny Loafer: The original style with a rounded toe and a leather saddle strap.
- Tassel Loafer: Features tassels on the vamp, adding a touch of flair.
- Horsebit Loafer: Has a metal bit across the vamp, a signature Gucci design.
- Driving Moccasin: Designed for driving, with rubber studs on the sole.
- Snaffle Loafer: Similar to the horsebit, but with a different metal embellishment.
These variations offer a range of options to suit different tastes and occasions.
The Future of the Penny Loafer
The penny loafer is a classic that is likely to endure for many years to come. Its timeless design, versatility, and association with preppy style ensure its continued popularity. As fashion trends evolve, the penny loafer will likely adapt and remain a staple in wardrobes around the world.
The penny loafer’s future is secure. Its ability to adapt and its timeless appeal ensure its place in the world of fashion.
Verdict
So, should you put pennies in penny loafers? The answer, like the shoe itself, is a matter of personal preference. There are arguments for and against the practice. The choice ultimately depends on your individual style, your appreciation for tradition, and your willingness to embrace the penny loafer’s history.
There’s no definitive right or wrong answer. If you enjoy the nostalgic charm and don’t mind the potential drawbacks, go for it! If you prefer a cleaner look or are concerned about the practicality, then leave the slot empty.
Ultimately, the penny loafer is a versatile and stylish shoe that can be worn in many ways. Whether or not you choose to insert a penny is just one small detail. The most important thing is to wear your loafers with confidence and enjoy their timeless appeal.
Recommended Products
