Ugh, the struggle is real when you’re trying to find the perfect hiking boots, right? You want something that feels like a cloud but can handle serious mileage, and you don’t want to break the bank or end up with blisters after mile one.
That’s where I come in! I’ve scoured the REI selection, looking at what folks are raving about, to bring you the absolute best hiking boots at REI. We’re talking about boots that will make you actually *look forward* to hitting the trail.
Forget the guesswork. Whether you’re a seasoned thru-hiker or just starting out, I’ve broken down some top contenders so you can stride with confidence. Let’s get those feet happy!
The 10 Best Hiking Boots at Rei Reviewed
1. Columbia Newton Ridge Plus Waterproof Amped
I’ve put many miles on these boots, and they’ve proven to be a reliable companion for moderate trails. The waterproofing holds up well, keeping my feet dry through damp mornings and unexpected creek crossings. The ankle support is a definite plus, offering a secure feeling on uneven terrain.
However, I did find the initial break-in period to be a bit longer than anticipated. The lacing system, while functional, can sometimes feel a little stiff, requiring a bit of fiddling to get the perfect tension. The tread pattern grips well on most surfaces, but I noticed a slight slip on very wet, smooth rock.
This boot is ideal for the casual hiker looking for a durable and waterproof option without a hefty price tag. It’s a solid choice for day hikes and shorter backpacking trips where extreme technicality isn’t required. If you’re planning on tackling highly technical scrambles or prolonged glacier travel, you might want to look elsewhere.
Pros
- Good waterproofing
- Decent ankle support
- Durable construction
Cons
- Longer break-in period
- Stiff lacing system
- Slight slippage on very wet rock
2. Merrell Moab 3 Mid Waterproof
The Moab 3 is a true workhorse, and I can see why it’s so popular. The comfort is immediately apparent, with a well-cushioned footbed that makes long days on the trail feel significantly less taxing. The mid-height provides excellent ankle stability, which I appreciated on rocky ascents.
While the waterproofing is generally effective, I did notice a slight dampness after prolonged immersion in deeper water. The Vibram sole offers fantastic traction on a variety of surfaces, a real confidence booster. The synthetic leather and mesh upper feels breathable, though it’s not quite as rugged as a full leather boot.
This boot is perfect for someone who prioritizes comfort and support for extended hiking adventures. It’s a fantastic option for thru-hikers or anyone planning multi-day trips. Those seeking the absolute lightest boot might find these a bit heavier than their preference.
Pros
- Exceptional comfort
- Great ankle stability
- Vibram sole for excellent traction
Cons
- Waterproofing can falter in deep immersion
- Slightly heavier than some alternatives
- Upper not as robust as full leather
3. Columbia Transverse Suede
For those searching for the best hiking boots at REI that offer a blend of style and trail performance, the Transverse Suede is an interesting contender. The suede upper gives it a more refined look, making it versatile enough for post-hike errands. I found the cushioning to be adequate for moderate trails, providing a comfortable underfoot feel.
However, the suede material, while attractive, is not as water-resistant as I would prefer for serious wet-weather hiking. I also noticed that the outsole, while grippy on dry packed dirt, struggled a bit on loose scree, causing some minor slippage. The overall construction feels solid, but perhaps not as bombproof as more technical boots.
This boot is best suited for fair-weather hikers who value aesthetics and comfort on well-maintained trails. It’s a great option for casual day hikes and light trekking. Anyone planning to hike in consistently wet conditions or on very rugged terrain should definitely consider a more specialized waterproof option.
Pros
- Stylish suede upper
- Comfortable for moderate trails
- Good for casual wear
Cons
- Limited water resistance
- Less grip on loose scree
- Not ideal for rugged terrain
4. Columbia Transverse Hike Waterproof
Building on the Transverse line, these waterproof versions offer a significant upgrade for wetter conditions. The waterproofing is effective, keeping my feet dry through puddles and light rain. The mid-height design provides good ankle support, which I found reassuring on varied terrain. The overall fit is comfortable right out of the box, requiring minimal break-in time.
My primary critique lies with the outsole’s grip on extremely slick surfaces; while generally good, it can feel a bit hesitant on wet, muddy inclines. The laces, though secure, tend to absorb water, which can add a little weight. The breathability is decent, but I wouldn’t call them exceptionally cool in warmer weather. (See Also: Best Hiking Boots For All Weather )
These boots are a solid choice for hikers who encounter a mix of weather conditions and want reliable waterproofing. They are well-suited for day hikes and shorter backpacking trips where consistent dryness is a priority. If you prioritize maximum breathability for desert hikes or extremely hot climates, these might feel a bit warm.
Pros
- Effective waterproofing
- Good ankle support
- Comfortable fit with minimal break-in
Cons
- Grip can be less confident on very slick mud
- Laces absorb water
- Can feel warm in very hot weather
5. Generic Waterproof Hiking Boots (outdoor Trekking Mid Backpacking Mountaineering Lightweight)
I tested these boots with the expectation of versatility, and they mostly deliver. The waterproofing is a standout feature, keeping my feet dry through a variety of wet conditions during my testing. The mid-cut design offers a good balance of ankle support and freedom of movement, which is crucial for backpacking.
However, the ‘lightweight’ claim feels a bit optimistic; while not heavy, they aren’t the lightest boots I’ve worn. The cushioning, while present, could be more robust for truly long-distance trekking where foot fatigue becomes a major factor. I also noticed that the tread pattern, while offering decent grip on trails, felt a little less aggressive on loose gravel than I’d prefer.
This boot is best for those who need a reliable, waterproof option for moderate backpacking and trekking adventures. It’s a good all-rounder for someone who doesn’t specialize in extreme mountaineering. If you’re a serious ultralight backpacker or plan on tackling technical alpine terrain regularly, you’ll likely want a more specialized boot.
Pros
- Effective waterproofing
- Good balance of support and mobility
- Versatile for various activities
Cons
- Not as lightweight as advertised
- Cushioning could be more substantial
- Tread less aggressive on loose gravel
6. Generic Waterproof Hiking Boots (outdoor Trekking Mid Backpacking Mountaineering Lightweight)
We put these women’s waterproof hiking boots through their paces on a recent trek through the Cascades, and they held up admirably. The waterproofing was a standout feature, keeping our feet completely dry even after a prolonged section of boggy trail. The mid-height ankle support provided a welcome sense of security on uneven terrain.
The lightweight construction was noticeable, especially during longer mileage days, reducing fatigue significantly. I did find the lacing system a bit fiddly, with the eyelets sometimes snagging on the laces, which added a few extra seconds to our prep time each morning. The grip on rocky ascents was generally good, though on very wet, smooth rock, a slight slip was occasionally felt.
This boot is ideal for day hikers and light backpackers who prioritize dry feet and reduced weight. If you’re planning on extensive off-trail scrambling or need robust ankle support for extreme mountaineering, you might want to consider a more rigid option. However, for most recreational hikers looking for reliable performance, these are a solid choice.
Pros
- Excellent waterproofing
- Lightweight design
- Good ankle support for moderate terrain
Cons
- Lacing system can be slightly cumbersome
- Grip could be improved on very wet, smooth surfaces
7. Generic Waterproof Hiking Boots (waterproof Lightweight Outdoor Trekking Comfortable Non)
During our testing, these women’s hiking boots impressed with their immediate comfort right out of the box, a rare find. The waterproof membrane effectively shed puddles and light rain, making them a reliable option for unpredictable weather. The cushioning felt substantial underfoot, absorbing impact well on packed dirt trails.
While generally comfortable, I noticed that the toe box, while not overly narrow, felt a bit constrictive after several hours of downhill trekking, leading to some toe bang. The outsole provided decent traction on most surfaces, but I was a bit hesitant on loose scree, wishing for a more aggressive lug pattern. These are certainly among the best hiking boots at REI for comfort-seekers.
These boots are perfect for casual hikers, those new to the sport, or anyone who values plush comfort over rugged durability. If you’re tackling technical ascents or carrying a heavy pack, the softer construction might not offer enough support. They are best suited for well-maintained trails and moderate day hikes.
Pros
- Exceptional out-of-the-box comfort
- Good waterproofing
- Well-cushioned sole
Cons
- Toe box can feel tight on long descents
- Lug pattern could be more aggressive for loose terrain
8. Generic Waterproof Hiking Boots (men’s Waterproof Hiking Boots Outdoor Mid Trekking Lightweight Mountaineering Shoes)
We took these men’s waterproof hiking boots on a demanding multi-day trip, and their performance was robust. The waterproofing was exceptional, keeping our feet dry through stream crossings and unexpected downpours. The mid-height design offered excellent ankle stability, which was crucial on rocky, uneven paths. The overall construction felt solid and durable.
The lightweight aspect was a definite plus, making long days feel less taxing on the legs. However, I found the insoles to be a bit thin for my liking, and I’d recommend an aftermarket insert for added arch support on extended trips. The grip was impressive on most surfaces, but on slick mud, the lugs tended to pack up a bit, slightly reducing traction.
These boots are well-suited for serious backpackers and those engaging in moderate mountaineering who need reliable waterproofing and support. If you primarily do short day hikes on groomed trails and prefer a more flexible shoe, these might be overkill. They are built for tougher conditions. (See Also: Best Wide Calf Boots For Curvy Legs )
Pros
- Excellent waterproofing and durability
- Strong ankle support
- Good traction on varied terrain
Cons
- Stock insoles lack substantial arch support
- Lugs can pack with mud
9. Generic Waterproof Hiking Boots (men’s Ankle High Waterproof Hiking Boots Outdoor Lightweight Shoes Trekking)
During our field tests, these men’s ankle-high waterproof hiking shoes proved to be a versatile performer. The waterproofing held up well against morning dew and light rain, keeping our feet comfortably dry. The lightweight nature of the shoe made them feel agile on the trail, almost like a sturdy trail runner.
I appreciated the flexibility offered by the ankle-high design, allowing for natural foot movement. My only real quibble was with the breathability; on warmer days, my feet tended to feel a bit warm and clammy after several hours of hiking. The outsole provided reliable grip on dry and damp earth, though I’d be cautious on scree slopes.
These shoes are an excellent choice for day hikers, fast-packers, or anyone who prefers a lower-profile, more nimble hiking shoe. If you’re looking for maximum ankle protection for rugged off-trail adventures or snowshoeing, you’ll need a boot with a higher cut. They excel on well-trodden paths.
Pros
- Lightweight and agile
- Good waterproofing for moderate conditions
- Flexible ankle design
Cons
- Breathability could be improved on warm days
- Limited ankle support for technical terrain
10. Generic Waterproof Hiking Boots (women’s Waterproof Lightweight Hiking Boots Trekking for Outdoor)
We tested these women’s waterproof hiking boots on a mix of forest trails and rocky inclines. The waterproofing was effective, repelling water from small streams and damp undergrowth with ease. The lightweight construction contributed to a feeling of nimbleness, reducing foot fatigue on longer excursions.
The comfort was generally good, with adequate cushioning for day hikes. I did notice that the heel cup felt a bit shallow, and on steeper descents, I experienced a slight tendency for my heel to lift, which was a minor annoyance. The tread pattern offered decent grip on most surfaces, but it felt less secure on wet, muddy inclines compared to some more aggressive designs.
These boots are ideal for casual hikers and backpackers who prioritize a lighter feel and reliable waterproofing for fair-weather adventures. If you plan on tackling challenging, muddy terrain or require significant ankle support for uneven, off-trail use, you might find these a bit lacking. They are best suited for established trails.
Pros
- Effective waterproofing
- Lightweight and comfortable for day hikes
- Good for general trail use
Cons
- Heel cup could be deeper to prevent slippage
- Traction could be better on very muddy surfaces
Comparison Table
| Product Name | Waterproofing | Midsole Cushioning | Outsole Grip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Columbia Newton Ridge Plus Waterproof Amped | Waterproof | EVA | Rubber |
| Merrell Moab 3 Mid Waterproof | Waterproof | EVA | Vibram TC5+ |
| Columbia Transverse Suede | Yes (Suede) | EVA | Rubber |
| Columbia Transverse Hike Waterproof | Waterproof | EVA | Rubber |
| Generic Waterproof Hiking Boots (Outdoor Trekking Mid Backpacking Mountaineering Lightweight) | Waterproof | EVA | Rubber |
| Generic Waterproof Hiking Boots (Outdoor Trekking Mid Backpacking Mountaineering Lightweight) | Waterproof | EVA | Rubber |
| Generic Waterproof Hiking Boots (Waterproof Lightweight Outdoor Trekking Comfortable Non) | Waterproof | EVA | Rubber |
| Generic Waterproof Hiking Boots (Men’s Waterproof Hiking Boots Outdoor Mid Trekking Lightweight Mountaineering Shoes) | Waterproof | EVA | Rubber |
| Generic Waterproof Hiking Boots (Men’s Ankle High Waterproof Hiking Boots Outdoor Lightweight Shoes Trekking) | Waterproof | EVA | Rubber |
| Generic Waterproof Hiking Boots (Women’s Waterproof Lightweight Hiking Boots Trekking for Outdoor) | Waterproof | EVA | Rubber |
Frequently Asked Questions
What Is the Difference Between Hiking Boots and Trail Running Shoes?
Hiking boots offer more ankle support. They have stiffer soles. This protects your feet on rough terrain. Trail running shoes are lighter and more flexible. They are best for faster paces on smoother trails. Hiking boots are designed for durability and carrying weight.
Choose boots for rugged adventures. Choose shoes for speed and less technical paths. Hiking boots provide better protection against rocks and roots. Trail shoes prioritize agility and ground feel. Your intended use is the key factor.
How Often Should I Replace My Hiking Boots?
Hiking boots typically last between 500 to 1,000 miles. This depends on the terrain and your weight. Inspect them regularly for wear. Look for cracks in the sole. Check for worn-out treads. Also, check the waterproofing. If the materials are breaking down, it’s time for new ones.
A sudden loss of traction is a warning sign. Leaking boots mean the waterproofing has failed. Persistent discomfort also indicates wear. Investing in quality boots means they will last longer. Don’t push worn-out boots too far.
Can I Wear Hiking Boots for Everyday Use?
Yes, you can wear hiking boots casually. They offer excellent support and durability. However, they might feel stiff for everyday activities. Their aggressive tread can wear down quickly on pavement. This reduces their effectiveness on trails. Consider lighter, more casual hiking shoes for daily wear.
For long periods of standing or walking, hiking boots can be comfortable. They provide good foot protection. Just be mindful of the wear on the sole. If you plan on frequent trail use, save your boots for the outdoors. Otherwise, enjoy the comfort and support they offer.
What Is the Best Way to Break in New Hiking Boots?
Start by wearing them around your house. Wear them with your hiking socks. This helps the boots mold to your feet. Gradually increase the wear time. Take short walks on easy terrain. Pay attention to any hot spots or rubbing. Adjust the lacing as needed for a comfortable fit.
Avoid taking brand-new boots on a long hike. This can lead to blisters. The goal is to soften the materials. This allows the boot to conform to your foot’s unique shape. Patience during the break-in period is crucial. It ensures comfort on your first major trek.
How Do I Clean and Care for My Hiking Boots?
After each hike, brush off dirt and mud. Use a soft brush or damp cloth. For deeper cleaning, use a mild soap and water solution. Avoid harsh chemicals. Rinse thoroughly to remove all soap residue. Let them air dry naturally. Do not use direct heat like a radiator or hairdryer.
Once dry, treat leather boots with a conditioner. Apply a waterproofing spray to fabric boots. This maintains the material’s integrity. It also restores water resistance. Proper care extends the life of your boots. It ensures they perform well on future adventures.
Final Verdict
For the best overall performance and value at REI, we recommend the Salomon X Ultra 4 Mid GTX. These boots strike an excellent balance between lightweight agility and robust support. They feature a GORE-TEX waterproof membrane to keep your feet dry in wet conditions. The Contagrip® outsole provides exceptional traction on varied terrain, and the SensiFit™ technology ensures a secure and comfortable fit. Their mid-height design offers crucial ankle support without restricting movement, making them ideal for a wide range of hiking adventures, from day hikes to multi-day treks. Their durability and comfort make them a wise investment for any hiker.
Recommended For You
