If you care about style and comfort, the laces you choose can change everything. Johnston and Murphy dress shoes deserve careful tying that balances form and function. In this guide, you’ll learn practical lacing that looks sharp and stays secure all day.
For a formal, secure fit, start with the classic crisscross pattern. The standard crisscross evenly distributes tension from the bottom to the top. If you want a cleaner silhouette, try bar lacing or a hidden-knot technique.
Step 1: Thread the lace through the bottom eyelets from the outside in. Step 2: Cross the laces and feed them through the opposite eyelets, pulling snug but not tight. Step 3: Finish with a gentle bow and test the fit with a short stride.
Use laces that match the shoe color for a seamless look, or go bold with a contrasting shade. Keep laces clean and replace worn pairs to prevent fraying and squeaks. Regular maintenance will help your Johnston and Murphy shoes stay comfortable and polished longer.
Choosing the Right Laces for Johnston & Murphy Shoes
Assessing Your Shoe Type and Eyelet Count
Johnston & Murphy shoes span formal Oxfords to rugged boots, and the key to comfortable, durable lacing is matching the technique to the shoe’s construction. Start by counting eyelets per side and noting whether the lacing is closed (balmoral) or open (derby style) because this affects how the lace threads and where stress concentrates. In dress shoes, you will typically see 4 to 6 eyelets per side, with closed lacing far more common; boots may present more eyelets but still benefit from a disciplined approach to length and tension.
Next, assess your goals for the pair. If you want a formal silhouette with clean lines, a thinner lace and lighter weave will disappear against the shoe. If you need more secure fit for long wear, choosing a waxed flat or waxed round lace can provide better bite and less slip without sacrificing aesthetics. This preliminary assessment sets the stage for selecting materials that suit both function and form.
Lace Material: Waxed, Flat, Round, and Their Effects
Different materials alter fit, feel, and durability, so understand how each behaves under real-world use. Flat laces, especially cotton or polyester blends, lie neatly and pair well with most dress shoes, producing a sleek silhouette. Round laces are common on boots and some derby styles, offering a different visual rhythm and sometimes greater durability in high-mobility settings. Waxed laces grip better and resist moisture, which helps maintain a sharp, formal look for Johnston & Murphy dress shoes.
Consider the geometry of the eyelets when choosing a lace type. Waxed flat laces can create a crisp line for Balmoral shoes, while thicker waxed round laces may feel stiffer in tight eyelets. Lacing tension should be uniform across all eyelets, and waxed laces tend to hold a knot better once secured. If you’re deciding between options, test tying with both to evaluate how smoothly each slides through the eyelets and how the finished look sits against the leather.
Measuring and Cutting Laces for Your Johnston & Murphy Style
Estimating Lace Length by Eyelet Count
Begin by counting eyelets per side and projecting how the lace will cross from each pair to the next. For most Johnston & Murphy Oxfords and Derbies with 4 to 6 eyelets per side, a 30 to 36-inch lace is typical, with longer lengths reserved for double knotted or wrap-style ties. If you switch to a longer tie or a bulkier knot, plan to increase length slightly to avoid crowding at the top.
Before trimming, lay the shoe on a flat surface and thread a length of string or spare lace along the eyelets to test how much length you’ll actually need. Mark the end when the lace would exit at the top eyelets; this gives you a concrete cutting reference. Cut straight and seal the ends with aglets or a fray-preventing method to keep the lace from unraveling during wear. (See Also: What Are Bricks in Shoes? The Shocking Truth!)
Choosing Color and Finish to Match Leather Tone
Color choice does more than aesthetics; it shapes the perception of formality and the wear pattern over time. For dark brown or black Johnston & Murphy shoes, pick laces in a shade close to the leather base to maintain a cohesive, elegant line. Avoid bright contrasts that can draw attention away from the shoe’s silhouette, unless you’re aiming for a deliberately fashion-forward statement.
Finish matters: waxed laces add a subtle sheen and resist moisture, which supports a crisp formal look. Matte cotton or polyester laces read more casual but can be appropriate for weeknight wear or business-casual ensembles. If you own multiple pairs, consider carrying a spare pair of black and dark brown laces so you can switch with ease to suit the occasion and lighting conditions.
The Classic Criss-Cross Lacing for Oxfords and Derby Shoes
Step-by-Step Criss-Cross Method
Begin with the lace ends even and thread through the bottom pair of eyelets from the outside, ensuring an equal initial length on both sides. Cross the right end over to the opposite eyelet, then pull the left end across to its corresponding eyelet, maintaining a flat, neat path along the tongue. Continue this alternating over-under pattern up to the top, keeping the lace flat and avoiding twists that create uneven gaps or press on the leather.
After the last cross, snug the lace gently but firmly so the eyelets sit evenly against the tongue without distorting the leather. Tie a secure knot that sits neatly on top of the shoe and trim any excess with careful, clean cuts. If your shoes feature a very slim tongue or a precision toe, verify visual symmetry in a mirror and adjust tension to avoid spillage into the vamp area.
Common Pitfalls and How to Avoid Them
Common pitfalls include laces twisting inside the eyelets, creating lopsided gaps, or pulling too tight and restricting circulation at the top. To avoid, periodically check for twists as you thread and make small adjustments before they become stubborn. Use a mirror or photo to confirm evenness along both sides and rethread if any eyelet sits out of alignment.
Another pitfall is using excessively long laces that bunch above the top eyelet or fray rapidly at the ends. If you notice slack at the top, shorten the length and consider a simpler knot than a bulky bow. Keep the lace path clean from the tongue, and avoid over-tightening which can distort the shoe’s shape over time.
The Straight-Lace (european Straight) Method for Fine Dress Shoes
When to Choose Straight-Lace
For the pinnacle of formality on closed-lacing Johnston & Murphy shoes, straight-lace offers a clean, uninterrupted line with minimal crossing complexity. It is especially suitable for balmoral Oxfords and other refined dress styles where the goal is an understated silhouette. However, this method demands careful eyelet alignment; misalignment can produce visible gaps or an uneven edge along the vamp.
Straight-lace tends to read slimmer and emphasizes the shoe’s silhouette, which some wearers prefer for formal ensembles. It also reduces bulk around the tongue, showcasing the leather’s natural texture and color. When you want the most polished appearance, straight-lace is a strong default choice, provided the eyelets sit evenly and the laces lie flat.
Technique and Alignment
Begin by threading the lace horizontally across from the inner edge to the outer edge of the bottom eyelets on both sides. Then bring the lace straight up to the next eyelet on the same side, creating parallel lines that bypass the vertical crossings and minimize bulk. Continue this pattern step by step until you reach the top, where you tie in the usual manner while preserving symmetry for a crisp finish. (See Also: What Shoes Does Bam Adebayo Wear? Find Out Now!)
The key to success with straight-lace is maintaining equal tension and keeping the laces centered on the tongue. Avoid any twists that push the lace out of alignment or cause the leather to crease. If either side starts to pull unevenly during wear, redo the lacing with a fresh start to restore the clean geometric line.
Alternative Lacing Techniques for Comfort and Fit
Hidden knot techniques place the knot at the topmost eyelets or behind the tongue so the knot stays out of sight when you wear the shoe. They rely on a tight termination near the top and careful spacing to avoid looseness. This approach keeps the surface smooth and reduces the chance of the knot unraveling during long days of wear.
To execute, lace normally down to the penultimate eyelet, then tie a tight double knot or surgeon’s knot behind the tongue before tucking the tails into the sides. If done correctly, the knot remains hidden while you still get a secure fit and a streamlined appearance. Practice a few attempts to ensure the knot holds without adding bulk at the top.
Lock Lacing and Extra Tie-Downs
Lock lacing uses a specialized threading approach to create a locked loop at the final eyelets, preventing heel slippage and maintaining consistent tension. This method is especially beneficial for dress shoes that tend to loosen after extended wear or during long commutes. The result is a steadier fit that doesn’t rely on aggressive knotting.
To implement, start with a standard criss-cross up to the penultimate eyelet, then form a small loop and feed the remaining lace through in a back-and-forth pattern to secure. Finish with a regular knot to anchor the lock. With practice, lock lacing can significantly improve security without sacrificing a refined look.
Lacing for Boots and Casual Johnston & Murphy Shoes
Captain’s Style Boot Lacing (for Boots)
Boots require longer laces and sometimes a different crossing pattern to maximize support and ease of use. For Johnston & Murphy leather boots, consider a simple criss-cross or a speed-lace approach that minimizes snagging while maintaining reliable closure. Choose rounded laces with a waxed finish for durability and a strong pull-through that resists fraying at the eyelets.
Additionally, select laces long enough to span the entire boot height and allow for a comfortable tie at the top. A double knot can help prevent looseness during walking and frequent movement, particularly on workday or outdoor activities. The key is balancing function with a look that remains cohesive with the boot’s rugged aesthetic.
Casual Loafers and Slip-Ons Without Laces
Many casual Johnston & Murphy loafers are laceless or use decorative tassels and elastic inserts rather than standard laces. If your casual pair does take laces, choose minimalistic, flat cotton laces in a tone that harmonizes with the shoe leather to preserve a neat, understated look. For slip-ons with hidden lacing, ensure the lacing does not show when the shoe is worn for a clean, streamlined profile.
Alternatively, you can convert to a simple tassel setup or select laces in the same color family as the leather to sustain a polished yet relaxed vibe. When decorating with tassels, keep proportion so the hardware remains a quiet accent rather than a distraction. In all cases, maintain consistent length between the two sides to ensure symmetry from the moment you tie the knot. (See Also: What Are Barefoot Shoes? Benefits, Styles & Where to Buy)
Maintenance and Troubleshooting: When Lacing Goes Wrong
Replacing Worn Laces and Securing Ends
Over time laces wear at the ends, fray, or lose color, which can undermine the shoe’s overall appearance and performance. Replace laces in pairs to maintain aesthetic balance and consistent wear characteristics. Start by removing the old laces, then clean the eyelets to remove debris that can accelerate wear during future use.
Thread the new laces from the outside of the bottom eyelets and tie a secure knot to anchor the start. After tying, trim the ends with a clean angle and cap the tips with aglets or a fray-preventing method to preserve longevity. Periodic replacement is a straightforward way to protect the shoe’s silhouette and your daily comfort.
Guarding Against Lace Slippage and Fraying
Properly tied laces reduce slippage, but you can add anti-fray products to the tips to extend life. If you notice frequent fraying at the ends, switch to round or waxed laces designed to resist wear. Regularly inspect eyelets for burrs or rough edges that can snag the lace and cause premature damage.
Store shoes with laces tied loosely to reduce strain on the lace loops and eyelets, which helps prevent deformation over time. If slippage remains an issue, consider locking the knot or using a slightly shorter length to maintain tension without compromising comfort. Routine care—including cleaning and occasional reseating of laces—keeps Johnston & Murphy shoes looking and feeling sharp.
Conclusion
Mastering how to lace Johnston & Murphy shoes is a blend of understanding the shoe’s construction, selecting the right lace material, and applying a technique that matches your objective—whether formal, secure, or casually stylish. The details matter: eyelet count, lace length, color harmony, and the discipline of even tension all contribute to comfort and silhouette. With deliberate practice, you can switch patterns to suit occasion, weather, or activity while preserving leather integrity.
From classic criss-cross to contemporary straight-lace, and from hidden knots to lock lacing, the strategies outlined here offer a practical toolkit. Use them to tailor fit, improve longevity, and elevate your overall look when you wear Johnston & Murphy shoes. Remember to select laces that respect the shoe’s tone and construction, test new techniques in private, and always prioritize a clean, balanced finish for maximum polish.
Recommended Products
